Lindsay poked holes in condom to get pregnant by Brian - Found

[lilpeppa40]

Hey guys, this community is so awesome. I'm looking for a story where Linds and Brian slept together a few times in college but Lindsay actually orchestrated the whole thing and poked holes in the condom so that she'd get pregnant by Brian. It didn't work and I believe at the end (years later) she's remorseful and tells Brian what she did. I hope my memory is serving me well and I hope someone can help. Thanks so much!

Comments

[britinmanor]

I'm thinking about this... is this the one where she also has JB for Brian to drink, but for herself, she has white grape juice in a wine bottle? Then when they wake up in the morning, she's all apologetic saying she didn't realize what she was doing the night before?

[lilpeppa40]

Maybe...? I'm sorry 😕 the trying to get pregnant part is really the only part of the story I remember. I'm grateful for you reaching out tho! What story is it that has that part you're thinking?

[eureka1]

This may be Nichelle Wellesly’s “Just the Two of Us”
https://kinnetikdreams.com/Adminftp/eFiction355/viewstory.php?sid=1288

[britinmanor]

The part I mentioned about the white grape juice is Nichelle's story, but that is also told in Sam Auerbach's POV in court, during an Alienation of Affection lawsuit against Lindsay. And there was no remorse on Lindsay's part.

[lilpeppa40]

Oh I see, well then sadly, (and after skimming it) as much I love Nichelle's stories, that's not it. Plus I'm also sure it's complete and she def expressed remorse because Brian didn't find out until she sat and told him and I think she and Mel stayed together. The only other vague memory that I think I have is that it might have been that Anti-Michael and trying to get Brian to be with him/split with Justin and it was sort of in the context of the fallout of the whole Michael situation that Lindsay knew she had to confess what she'd done all the years before. (Might be mixing up another story but I also think it had Lindsay having an affair with a married woman at a wedding, again while younger). Oh and I do believe she used to take Brian with her to fancy country club events.

[lilpeppa40]

Oh my gosh, I something you guys said made me think deeper to remember details and so I remembered Brian had amnesia and then the pieces just fell into place and kick-started my own dusty memory. The story is "I Knew I Loved You" by Nadine1
https://archiveofourown.org/works/9297161?view_full_work=true

Thank you so much for all your help!

[britinmanor]

YES, YES, YES!!!!!!!!!!! YOU GO GIRL! I just knew I knew it too. The wedding incident was when Lindsay was younger, right?

[lilpeppa40]

It's such a great story! Yep, all the wedding and Brian trapping stuff took place when they were younger